UPSC PYQPrelims 2012

Civil Services Examination · Question 40

Only six roads A, B, C, P, Q and R connect a military camp to the rest of the country. Only one out of A, P and R is open at any one time. If B is closed, so is Q. Only one of A and B is open during storms. P is closed during floods. In this context, which one of the following statements is correct?

  1. Under normal conditions only three roads are open.

  2. During storms at least one road is open.

  3. During floods only three roads are open.

  4. During calamities all roads are closed.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (B) During storms at least one road is open.

Explanation

Given: Roads = {A, B, C, P, Q, R}. Exactly 1 of {A, P, R} is open; B closed ⇒ Q closed; during storms, exactly 1 of {A, B} is open; during floods, P is closed. Check Option b: During storms, 'only one of A and B is open' means one of the two roads (A or B) is definitely open ⇒ at least one road is open during storms. Why Other Options Fail: Under normal conditions or floods, B, Q, C and one of {A, R} can all 4 be open (so a and c fail); and during storms at least one road is open (so d fails). Result: During storms at least one road is open. Correct Answer: (b) During storms at least one road is open.

Diagram explaining the answer