UPSC PYQPrelims 2012

Civil Services Examination · Question 43

Consider the following statements: 1. All X-brand cars parked here are white. 2. Some of them have radial tyres. 3. All X-brand cars manufactured after 1986 have radial tyres. 4. All cars are not X-brand. Which one of the following conclusions can be drawn from the above statements?

  1. Only white cars are parked here.

  2. Some white X-brand cars with radial tyres are parked here.

  3. Cars other than X-brand cannot have radial tyres.

  4. Most of the X-brand cars are manufactured before 1986.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (B) Some white X-brand cars with radial tyres are parked here.

Explanation

Given: Statement 1 says all X-brand cars parked here are white; Statement 2 says some of those parked X-brand cars have radial tyres. Combine 1 & 2: Since all parked X-brand cars are white and some of them have radial tyres ⇒ some white X-brand cars with radial tyres are parked here. Eliminate a, c, d: Non-X-brand cars parked here need not be white (a fails) and may have radial tyres (c fails); 'some' does not imply 'most' were made before 1986 (d fails). Result: Some white X-brand cars with radial tyres are parked here. Correct Answer: (b) Some white X-brand cars with radial tyres are parked here.

Diagram explaining the answer