UPSC PYQPrelims 2012

Civil Services Examination · Question 41

Examine the following statements: 1. None but students are members of the club. 2. Some members of the club are married persons. 3. All married persons are invited for dance. Which one of the following conclusions can be drawn from the above statements?

  1. All students are invited for dance.

  2. All married students of the club are invited for dance.

  3. All members of the club are married persons.

  4. None of the above conclusions can be drawn.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (B) All married students of the club are invited for dance.

Explanation

Given: (1) None but students are club members ⇒ Club ⊂ Students; (2) Some club members are married ⇒ Club ∩ Married ≠ ∅; (3) All married persons are invited for dance ⇒ Married ⊂ Invited. Combine 1, 2 & 3: The members of the club who are married are 'married students of the club' (from 1 & 2). Since all married persons are invited for dance (from 3) ⇒ all married students of the club are invited for dance. Eliminate a & c: Unmarried students need not be invited (so a fails), and only some club members are married (so c fails). Result: All married students of the club are invited for dance. Correct Answer: (b) All married students of the club are invited for dance.

Diagram explaining the answer