UPSC PYQPrelims 2015

Civil Services Examination · Question 55

Consider the following statements followed by two conclusions: Statements: Some men are great. Some men are wise. Conclusion I: Men are either great or wise. Conclusion II: Some men are neither great nor wise. Which one of the following is correct?

  1. Only conclusion I is valid

  2. Only conclusion II is valid

  3. Both the conclusions are valid

  4. Neither of the conclusions is valid

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (D) Neither of the conclusions is valid

Explanation

Given / Concept: Statements — "Some men are great" and "Some men are wise". Test Conclusion I: From two particular affirmative ("Some") statements, we cannot conclude a universal statement that all men must be either great or wise. So Conclusion I is invalid. Test Conclusion II: Two affirmative statements cannot yield a definite negative conclusion ("Some men are neither great nor wise"), because it is possible that the union of great men and wise men covers all men. So Conclusion II is invalid. Result: Neither Conclusion I nor Conclusion II follows definitely from the given statements. Correct Answer: (d) Neither of the conclusions is valid

Diagram explaining the answer