UPSC PYQPrelims 2015

Civil Services Examination · Question 63

Passage – 3 The conflict between man and State is as old as State history. Although attempts have been made for centuries to bring about a proper adjustment between the competing claims of State and the individual, the solution seems to be still far off. This is primarily because of the dynamic nature of human society where old values and ideas constantly yield place to new ones. It is obvious that if individuals are allowed to have absolute freedom of speech and action, the result would be chaos, ruin and anarchy. The author's viewpoint can be best summed up in which of the following statements?

  1. The conflict between the claims of State and individual remains unresolved.

  2. Anarchy and chaos are the obvious results of democratic traditions.

  3. Old values, ideas and traditions persist despite the dynamic nature of human society.

  4. Constitutional guarantee of freedom of speech is not in the interest of society.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (A) The conflict between the claims of State and individual remains unresolved.

Explanation

Given / Concept: Passage 3 discusses the centuries-old conflict between the State and the individual and why its resolution remains elusive. Check Direct Text Support: The passage states, "Although attempts have been made for centuries to bring about a proper adjustment between the competing claims of State and the individual, the solution seems to be still far off." Eliminate Other Options: Option (b) blames "democratic traditions" and (d) blames "constitutional guarantee" (whereas the passage only warns against "absolute freedom"); option (c) contradicts the text ("old values and ideas constantly yield place to new ones"). Result: Thus, the conflict between the claims of State and individual remains unresolved. Correct Answer: (a) The conflict between the claims of State and individual remains unresolved.

Diagram explaining the answer