UPSC PYQPrelims 2015

Civil Services Examination · Question 62

Passage – 2 No Right is absolute, exclusive or inviolable. The Right of personal property, similarly, has to be perceived in the larger context of its assumed legitimacy. The Right of personal property should unite the principle of liberty with that of equality, and both with the principle of cooperation. In the light of the argument in the above passage, which one of the following statements is the most convincing explanation?

  1. The Right of personal property is a Natural Right duly supported by statutes and scriptures.

  2. Personal property is a theft and an instrument of exploitation. The Right of personal property is therefore violative of economic justice.

  3. The Right of personal property is violative of distributive justice and negates the principle of cooperation.

  4. The comprehensive idea of economic justice demands that the Right of each person to acquisition of property has to be reconciled with that of others.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (D) The comprehensive idea of economic justice demands that the Right of each person to acquisition of property has to be reconciled with that of others.

Explanation

Given / Concept: Passage 2 argues that no right is absolute or exclusive, and the Right of personal property must unite liberty, equality, and cooperation. Eliminate Contradictory Options: Option (a) brings in "Natural Right" and "scriptures" (not in passage), while (b) and (c) condemn personal property as theft or anti-cooperation, contradicting the passage's call to harmonize it. Connect Liberty, Equality, and Cooperation: Uniting individual liberty with equality and cooperation means that one person's right to acquire property is not exclusive and must be harmonized with the rights of others. Result: The Right of each person to acquisition of property has to be reconciled with that of others. Correct Answer: (d) The comprehensive idea of economic justice demands that the Right of each person to acquisition of property has to be reconciled with that of others.

Diagram explaining the answer