UPSC PYQPrelims 2019

Civil Services Examination · Question 63

Passage – 2 In a study, scientists compared the microbiomes of poorly nourished and well nourished infants and young children. Gut microbes were isolated from faecal samples of malnourished and healthy children. The microbiome was "immature" and less diverse in malnourished children compared to the better developed "mature" microbiome found in healthy children of the same age. According to some studies, the chemical composition of mother's milk has shown the presence of a modified sugar (sialylated oligosaccharides). This is not utilized by the baby for its own nutrition. However, the bacteria constituting the infant's microbiome thrive on this sugar which serves as their food. Malnourished mothers have low levels of this sugar in their milk. Consequently, the microbiomes of their infants fail to mature. That in turn, leads to malnourished babies. Which one of the following is the most logical, rational and crucial inference that can be derived from the above passage?

  1. If malnourished condition in children is caused by gut bacteria, it cannot be treated.

  2. The guts of malnourished babies should be inoculated with mature microbiomes.

  3. Babies of malnourished mothers should be fed with dairy milk fortified with sialylated oligosaccharides instead of mother's milk.

  4. Research on benign effects of gut bacteria on nutrition has policy implications.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (D) Research on benign effects of gut bacteria on nutrition has policy implications.

Explanation

Analyze Passage: The passage explains a scientific discovery: a modified sugar (sialylated oligosaccharides) in mother's milk feeds beneficial gut bacteria, helping the infant's microbiome mature; malnourished mothers have low levels of this sugar, leading to immature microbiomes and malnourished babies. Eliminate Extreme/Prescriptive Options: ⇒ (a) False: Identifying the mechanism does not mean it cannot be treated. ⇒ (b) & (c) Unsupported clinical prescriptions: The passage does not advocate faecal/microbiome inoculation or replacing mother's milk with fortified dairy milk. Result: The discovery that beneficial gut bacteria and maternal milk composition govern infant malnutrition carries major public-health and nutrition policy implications. Correct Answer: (d) Research on benign effects of gut bacteria on nutrition has policy implications.

Diagram explaining the answer