UPSC PYQPrelims 2019

Civil Services Examination · Question 85

In the context of polity, which one of the following would you accept as the most appropriate definition of liberty?

  1. Protection against the tyranny of political rulers

  2. Absence of restraint

  3. Opportunity to do whatever one likes

  4. Opportunity to develop oneself fully

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (D) Opportunity to develop oneself fully

Explanation

Given / Concept: In constitutional political theory (as explained in NCERT Class XI Political Theory, Chapter 2: 'Freedom'), liberty has both a negative dimension (absence of external constraints) and a positive dimension (enabling conditions for self-development). Evaluating Options a, b, c: ⇒ Option (c) ('doing whatever one likes') is 'licence', which destroys the liberty of others. ⇒ Option (b) ('absence of restraint') captures only the narrow negative aspect of liberty; in a civilized polity, reasonable restraints (laws) are essential for everyone to enjoy liberty. ⇒ Option (a) is only a partial safeguard. Evaluating Option d: In its positive and most comprehensive sense (reflected in the Preamble to the Constitution of India and Harold Laski's definition), liberty means providing every individual the opportunity and enabling conditions to develop one's potential/personality fully (Option d ✓). Result: 'Opportunity to develop oneself fully' is the most appropriate definition of liberty. Related Facts: • Isaiah Berlin ('Two Concepts of Liberty', 1958): Distinguished between Negative Liberty ('freedom from' external interference) and Positive Liberty ('freedom to' achieve self-realization and self-mastery). • Preamble to the Indian Constitution: Secures to all citizens 'LIBERTY of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship'. Correct Answer: (d) Opportunity to develop oneself fully

Diagram explaining the answer