Civil Services Examination · Question 4
Directions: This item contains a question followed by two statements. Answer the item using the following instructions: (a) Select this option if the question can be answered using one of these statements alone, but cannot be answered using the other statement. (b) Select this option if the question can be answered using either statement alone. (c) Select this option if the question can be answered using both the statements together, but cannot be answered using either statement alone. (d) Select this option if the question cannot be answered even using any of the statements. Question: X is a collection of certain odd numbers whereas Y is a collection of certain even numbers. T consists of the numbers all of which are either from X or from Y. Is every number of T from Y? Statement I: The sum of any two numbers belonging to T is even. Statement II: If both p and q are picked from T, then (p − 1)q is even.
Show answer & explanationShow explanation
Answer: (D) Cannot be answered even using any of the statements
Given / Concept: X contains odd numbers and Y contains even numbers. We must check whether all elements of T belong to Y (i.e. are even). Check Statement I: The sum of any two numbers in T is even ⇒ all numbers in T have the same parity (either all odd from X, or all even from Y) ⇒ not sufficient. Check Statement II: (p − 1)q is even for any p, q in T ⇒ if all elements of T are odd, (p − 1) is even; if all elements of T are even, q is even ⇒ both all-odd and all-even sets satisfy Statement II. Combine I and II: Both statements together are satisfied when T consists entirely of odd numbers from X (e.g. T = {3, 5}) and also when T consists entirely of even numbers from Y (e.g. T = {2, 4}). Result: Even using both statements together, we cannot determine whether every number of T is from Y. Shortcut: In (p − 1)q, an odd p makes (p − 1) even, while an even q makes q even — so pure-odd and pure-even sets both work. Correct Answer: (d) Cannot be answered even using any of the statements
