UPSC PYQPrelims 2018

Civil Services Examination · Question 9

Passage—3 I am a scientist, privileged to be somebody who tries to understand nature using the tools of science. But it is also clear that there are some really important questions that science cannot really answer, such as : Why is there something instead of nothing? Why are we here? In those domains, I have found that faith provides a better path to answers. I find it oddly anachronistic that in today's culture there seems to be a widespread presumption that scientific and spiritual views are incompatible. Which of the following is the most logical and rational inference that can be made from the above passage?

  1. It is the faith and not science that can finally solve all the problems of mankind.

  2. Science and faith can be mutually complementary if their proper domains are understood.

  3. There are some very fundamental questions which cannot be answered by either science or faith.

  4. In today's culture, scientific views are given more importance than spiritual views.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (B) Science and faith can be mutually complementary if their proper domains are understood.

Explanation

Given: The author (a scientist) uses science to understand nature and faith to address existential questions ('In those domains, faith provides a better path'), while rejecting the presumption that scientific and spiritual views are incompatible. Analyze domains: Science answers how nature works; faith addresses why we exist ('in those domains'). Synthesize author's conclusion: Rejecting their incompatibility means science and faith can coexist and complement each other when their respective domains are recognized. Eliminate options: (a) and (c) contradict the text; (d) is not stated (the text only mentions a presumption of incompatibility). Correct Answer: (b) Science and faith can be mutually complementary if their proper domains are understood.

Diagram explaining the answer